Solved: Remote vs Distributed vs Ethernet io drops

If you want to learn more, please visit our website sonnepower.

Well, it really boils down to what do you want to do with the IO that is physically separated from the main PLC.  There are so many factors to select a path. You have to functionality, ease of use, cost, and now availability.  I think the confusion comes from how Schneider defines their hardware.

For Schneider in general they talk about "Remote IO" and use it synonymously with "Ethernet Remote IO (ERIO)" which is their time deterministic IO system.  This is used for mission-critical timing.  This may be where you have seen the "Ethernet IO drop"...same as "ERIO" in Schneider's world.  This is the M580 PLC family with x80 hardware.

For Schneider "distributed IO" is any other (what the industry, in general, would call) "remote IO" hardware. This is the confusion. This IO, is non-time deterministic IO that is physically separated from the main PLC connected by any serial or ethernet-based network. 

For "distributed IO". a plc would send a query to the IO system that is physically some distance away.   Simple application...read some inputs....figure out what to do and send some outputs whenever the processor gets to sending the update.  These are the M340, M200 series PLCs and would be any of the distributed IO systems you choose.  TM3 bus coupler, Advantys STB, Turck, Wago, Weidmuller, etc.

In the world of industrial automation and control systems, the effective management of input and output (I/O) signals is essential for seamless operation. Distributed I/O and Remote I/O are two common solutions employed to address this need. However, these two approaches differ significantly in terms of their architecture, functionality, and applications. In this comprehensive guide, we, SonnePower, will explore the distinctions between Distributed I/O and Remote I/O systems, helping you understand when to use each and how they impact industrial processes.

 Distributed I/O System

A Distributed I/O system, also known as Decentralized I/O, involves the placement of I/O modules in close proximity to the field devices they interface with. In this setup, the I/O modules are typically located in the field, near sensors, actuators, or other devices. These modules are connected to a central controller or PLC through a communication network, such as Ethernet, Profibus, or Modbus. The central controller manages and coordinates the I/O modules' operations.

 Key Characteristics of Distributed I/O Systems:

1. Proximity to Field Devices: In a Distributed I/O system, I/O modules are placed in physical proximity to the field devices they control or monitor. This reduces the length of wiring runs and minimizes signal loss and interference.

2. Reduced Wiring Complexity: With I/O modules situated close to the field devices, there is a significant reduction in the amount of cabling required. This simplifies the installation process and reduces overall wiring costs.

3. Fast Response Times: Distributed I/O systems are known for their fast response times because of the minimal signal propagation delay. This makes them suitable for applications that require real-time control and monitoring.

4. Scalability: These systems are highly scalable, allowing additional I/O modules to be easily integrated as needed. This scalability makes them suitable for applications with changing I/O requirements.

5. Local Control: In some cases, Distributed I/O systems can provide local control and monitoring at the field level, enhancing operational flexibility.

 Applications of Distributed I/O Systems:

Distributed I/O systems are commonly used in various industrial applications, including manufacturing, process control, and building automation. Some specific examples include:

- Conveyor systems in manufacturing plants

- Control of sensors and actuators in processing units

- Lighting and HVAC control in building management systems

- Material handling and sorting systems

 Remote I/O System

A Remote I/O system, also known as Centralized I/O, follows a different architecture. In this setup, I/O modules are located remotely from the field devices they interface with. Instead of being close to the sensors and actuators, Remote I/O modules are typically positioned in a centralized control panel or cabinet. These modules are connected to a central controller or PLC using communication networks like Ethernet, Profibus, or Modbus.

For more distributed i oinformation, please contact us. We will provide professional answers.

 Key Characteristics of Remote I/O Systems:

1. Centralized Location: Remote I/O modules are centralized in a control panel or cabinet, often situated away from the field devices. This centralization simplifies the maintenance and management of I/O modules.

2. Wiring Length: Wiring runs from the field devices to the Remote I/O modules can be relatively long, depending on the application. This makes Remote I/O systems suitable for situations where field devices are dispersed over larger areas.

3. Reduced Environmental Exposure: Remote I/O modules are typically protected within control panels or cabinets, reducing their exposure to harsh environmental conditions, such as extreme temperatures or dust.

4. Easier Troubleshooting: With Remote I/O systems, diagnosing and troubleshooting issues can be more straightforward due to the centralization of I/O modules. Technicians can access and test the modules in a controlled environment.

5. Control Cabinet Organization: These systems contribute to cleaner and more organized control cabinets, as the I/O modules are neatly housed within the cabinet.

 Applications of Remote I/O Systems:

Remote I/O systems are particularly well-suited for applications that involve:

- Oil and gas installations, where sensors and actuators may be distributed across vast areas

- Water and wastewater treatment plants, which have multiple remote measurement points

- Conveyor systems in large distribution centers

- Remote monitoring and control of equipment in hazardous environments

 Choosing Between Distributed and Remote I/O

The decision to implement a Distributed I/O or Remote I/O system depends on a variety of factors, including the nature of the application, the layout of field devices, environmental conditions, and operational requirements. Here are some considerations to guide your choice:

1. Wiring Length: If the distance between field devices and the control system is extensive, a Remote I/O system may be more practical due to its capability to support long wiring runs.

2. Environmental Conditions: In harsh or hazardous environments where field devices are exposed to extreme temperatures, moisture, or dust, Remote I/O systems, with their protected centralized location, can be a better choice.

3. Response Time: Applications requiring fast response times and real-time control often benefit from Distributed I/O systems, as they minimize signal propagation delays.

4. Wiring Costs: If minimizing wiring costs is a priority, a Distributed I/O system, with its reduced cabling requirements, is an advantageous option.

5. Scalability: Consider the potential for future expansion or changes in I/O requirements. Distributed I/O systems are typically more scalable due to their flexibility in adding I/O modules.

6. Maintenance and Troubleshooting: Evaluate the ease of maintenance and troubleshooting. Remote I/O systems can provide a more controlled environment for these tasks.

 Conclusion

SonnePower understands the importance of choosing the right approach for managing input and output signals in industrial automation. Our advanced IO modules offer flexible solutions that cater to both Distributed I/O and Remote I/O systems. With SonnePower, you can seamlessly adapt to varying wiring lengths, environmental conditions, response times, scalability requirements, and maintenance needs. Empower your control solutions with our innovative IO modules, designed to address the unique operational challenges of your industry.
Trust SonnePower for reliable, efficient, and adaptable IO solutions that drive productivity and success in industrial automation. Contact us right now to get the most competitive quotation!

For more information, please visit distributed i/o modules.